Island Club Dining

Places To Eat and Pubs to Drink

Blue Marlin Bar & Grill

Caribbean themed, complete with a tiki bar and palm trees, this bar is located at The Put in Bay Resort and Conference Center. There is a swim up bar within the heated pool, and a 40 person jacuzzi for guests to enjoy. Put-in-Bay Pizza Co. cooks up fantastic finger-licking food daily.


Phone: 419-285-7427

Boardwalk Restaurant

Location, location, location! The Boardwalk is situated right on the harbor near the city docks. Enjoy the spectacular panoramic views of the boats in the harbor and the surrounding islands from the various decks and patios. Most notably is the lobster bisque. It's ridiculously delicious!


Phone: 419-285-3695


Ahoy mates! One step into this restaurant and you'll feel like Jack Sparrow himself navigating the Black Pearl. Inside it feels as if you are in a vessel sailing in open waters, as the layout is that of an upside down boat. Put-in-Bay legend Pat Dailey can be found at this PIB hotspot.


Phone: 419-285-5665

Cameo Pizza

Mamma Loccoco, the matriarch founder, began by cooking Old World Style Italian food for her friends in family in her own kitchen. So in 1936 Sandusky, Ohio Cameo Pizza was founded with these core family values. So stop on by for a pizza pie and tell your hunger bye bye. Forget about it!


Phone: 419-285-4444

Chicken Patio

Directly to the right of the famed Roundhouse Bar is the Chicken Patio. This essential island tradition boasts a wine basted 1/2 chicken dinner that includes corn on the cob, potato salad, and a dinner roll. The chicken is cooked onsite on a large charcoal grill, and is served directly from it. The patio overlooks DiRiviera park in downtown Put-in-Bay.


Phone: 419-285-3581

Fish Shack

Located inside Boardwalk restaurant, the Fish Shack's signature items include breaded Lake Erie walleye and perch sandwiches. A great addition to these sandwiches are their renowned onion rings. They also serve fresh breaded Walleye and Lake Erie Yellow Perch.


Phone: 419-285-3695

Frosty Pizza

Leave your inhibitions and cover charge at the door; you won't need either! For over 50 years Frosty's has been delivering delicious pizza and icy cold beer, while never charging a cover charge. Also, Frosty's is noted for their excellent Bloody Mary's and breakfast.


Phone: 419-285-3278

Little Galley

Want some great lunch with a fantastic view? Check out the Little Galley, located inside the Boardwalk restaurant. So come grab a juicy burger and french fries and enjoy the spectacular view from the outdoor patio.


Phone: 419-285-3695


Positioned near the public docks and the park, Mossbacks is a great choice for a wonderful served meal. The rich interior is very inviting, complete with gorgeous wood working. This upscale, casual restaurant specializes in walleye, perch, steak, and chops. Lunch and dinner are served daily.


Phone: 419-285-8888

Mr. Ed's Bar & Grille

One of Put-in-Bays most popular, premier dining experiences. Renowned for their oversized sandwiches, fresh homemade soups, daily dinner specials and especially their chicken wings. You can't truly say you've had good wings until you've had them at Mr. Ed's!


Phone: 419-285-3101


Hooligans is Put-in-Bay's Original 'Irish Pub and a Snug, With Music and Grub.' Featuring Reuben and Corned Beef sandwiches, Fish & Chips, Shepherd's Pie and other delicious menu items. We also boast a wide variety of Irish Whiskeys and all your favorite spirits. Enjoy any one of our Draught Beers including, of course, Guinness -- all poured in our 20oz Pint Glasses! Beautiful inside and out, Hooligans is proud to be your "Getaway at the Bay!"


Phone: 419-285-8000


The place to be for breakfast! For over 20 years Pasquale's has been putting out delicious breakfasts from light, fluffy omelette's to stacks of pancakes. They are also open for lunch and offer a variety of sandwiches, wraps, and pizzas. Located in the middle of downtown Put in Bay.


Phone: 419-285-8600

Put in Bay Brewing Company

There's no more of an appropriate place for a brewery than here on Put in Bay. They have a full service kitchen which is known for excellent appetizers, beef braised short ribs, and Lake Erie perch. Also, they offer late night pizza by the slice.


Phone: 419-285-4677


Hungry? Late night? Eat Fresh. This store opened in the summer of 2007, and is located in the Commodore Hotel lobby. The sub sandwiches are made with bread baked daily, and topped with a variety of fresh toppings. Personal pizzas can also be found here, and are ready in 90 seconds.


Phone: 419-285-3695

Upper Deck Restaurant

Overlooking the Bay above the Boardwalk Restaurant, you'll find this well appointed full service restaurant. Tableside service allows guests to sit back, relax and basque in the beauty of the bay with a bowl of bisque. The Upper Deck also has great live entertainment


Phone: 419-285-3695

Village Bakery

Bright and early every morning the ovens are baking up tasty pastries, donuts, and other delectable confections. Breakfast sandwiches are also available, as is fresh coffee and cappuccino. The lunch offerings include mostly sandwiches and wraps, and can be enjoyed on the outside patio.


Phone: 419-285-5351

The Goat Soup & Whiskey

Come on in and let loose. The Goat offers a wide selection of fresh made soups, sandwiches, and dinner selections. Enjoy your meal inside in their spacious dining area, or opt to enjoy the fresh air while dining outside on their patio. The Goat is located on Catawaba Ave.


Phone: 419-285-4628

Free Weekend Contest

We are happy to enter you into our contest and add you to our monthly newsletter!

Entry form

How to find us